Why trains suck
This morning I had the wondrous privilege of travelling on the packed commuter service from Widnes to Birchwood. This service has a bad record, for a commuter service you would expect that it would have the correct number of carriages, this service demands at least four but it regularly turns up with just two, causing everyone to try and ram in.
At Warrington station we had a “complainer” as I call them, cursing and swearing about the train company and how he doesn’t like to be cramed into small places. The guy did have a point, and I’ve often said similar things. The issue I had was this guy’s persistence that it was his right to get on the train and he proceeded to swear at the first person who responded with “no room”.
We arrived at Birchwood station, a First Transpennie station, we were greeted by ticket inspectors, several people complained about the train and the general tone we were greated with was “Oh, East Midlands? Not our company”. Privatisation has really done nothing for the network except split up the “blame” to different companies who don’t give a damn. On our line, the City Line from Liverpool to Manchester, we have 3 operators. Northern Rail, First Transpennie, and East Midlands. Northern operate the local services stopping at all stations and also own the “minor” stations, First Transpennie operate a single service through this line own the bigger stations (Warrington, Birchwood). So investment and ownership is very split, and so is the responsibility.
I suspect with British Rail, we would have a worse overall service but at least the responsibility is centralised, if the trains failed it was their fault. The goverment belived that privatisation would bring new investment into the service, instead local services have stagnated while money earning routes, such as the West Coast Mainline see massive investment.
It’s past the point of saving, lets just hope the goverment notices and works something out.

As a nation I think we’re just starting to debunk the myth that the private sector is any less able to cock things up than the public sector.
Michael
2 Oct 08 at 11:22 pm
One thing that has always puzzled me about privatisation, if the train you or I get on is an East Midlands, and we get off at a Transpennine Station, why do Transpennine get the ticket revenue? Obviously, if East Midlands sent a conductor down the train they would get the revenue, but how do Transpennine justify taking the ticket money when all they have done is provided a generally sub-par station? I know ticket prices are the same irrelevant of which train service you get on, but Transpennine wash their hands of the problem yet sit back and happily take the money. It’s hardly fair is it?
Salkunh
3 Oct 08 at 9:28 am